Redtail CRM vs Referral Maker

Last Updated:

Our analysts compared Redtail CRM vs Referral Maker based on data from our 400+ point analysis of CRM Software, user reviews and our own crowdsourced data from our free software selection platform.

Redtail CRM Software Tool
Referral Maker Software Tool

Product Basics

Redtail CRM is a web-based client relationship management solution tailored specifically for financial advisors and their teams. It helps simplify client management, automate workflows and improve collaboration within financial services firms. The platform also includes compliance features to meet regulatory requirements and offers opportunity tracking for managing sales pipelines.

It’s best suited for mid-sized to large financial advisory firms that need complex workflow management and extensive customization. It's helpful for teams managing intricate client relationships and requiring integration with other financial software.

Users like Redtail's feature set and its ability to handle complex workflows. They find the customization options useful, though they come with a steep learning curve. Some users report challenges with the system's speed, occasional glitches and a sometimes overwhelming interface. The quality of customer support has mixed reviews, with some users finding it lacking in responsiveness.

Starting at $39 per month per user, Redtail CRM is an affordable solution in the long term, especially given its industry-specific features. However, some key features, such as email integration, may come with additional costs.

read more...
Referral Maker is a cloud-based solution that helps businesses manage leads, client feedback, databases, performance tracking and more from a central location. With features like a Dashboard and Priority Action Center, it boosts productivity and lead-to-close ratio.

Suited for businesses of all sizes, it maximizes sales efficiency and expands operations through relational marketing.
read more...
$99 Monthly
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
$49 Monthly
Get a free price quote
Tailored to your specific needs
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Small 
i
Medium 
i
Large 
i
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Windows
Mac
Linux
Android
Chromebook
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile
Cloud
On-Premise
Mobile

Product Assistance

Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Documentation
In Person
Live Online
Videos
Webinars
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support
Email
Phone
Chat
FAQ
Forum
Knowledge Base
24/7 Live Support

Product Insights

  • Switch Without the Hassle: Easily change CRM providers with Redtail's free database migrations. Once you activate your subscription, they provide complimentary database imports from nearly every major solutions provider.
  • Connect With Your Favorite Tools: Redtail offers integration with popular financial software, including portfolio management systems, accounting software and compliance tools. This keeps all your important information in sync across platforms.
  • Stay Compliant With Ease: The platform incorporates strong compliance features designed specifically for the financial services industry. These tools help firms adhere to regulatory requirements like SEC Rule 17a-4(f).
  • Quickly Generate Custom Reports: With Redtail, you can run reports for almost any scenario you can think of. Choose from a wide range of standard reports and exports, or create your own custom exports to fit your needs.
read more...
  • Simplify Access: A simple, easy-to-use interface improves adoption rates while reducing the learning curve. 
  • Ensure Data Security: Ensure data safety through privacy-preserving encrypted data processing and automated scheduled backups. 
  • Leverage Cloud-Based Deployment: Leverage a cloud-based suite that prevents hardware investments and supplies operational agility. 
  • Get Mobile Accessibility: Access the software through a mobile website login and dedicated mobile apps over Android and iOS devices. 
  • Avoid Data Duplicity: Run duplicity scans to solve data duplicity and redundancy issues while managing contacts, listings and document data. 
  • Increase Revenue: Boost revenue by optimizing sales processes and improving win rates for faster ramp-up times and larger deal sizes.  
read more...
  • Automated Workflows: The workflow feature allows you to design automated processes that mirror your existing business practices. This not only creates a clear trail of accountability for each task but also ensures you don’t overlook any important step.
  • Extensive Integrations: Redtail continuously expands its integration capabilities with industry partners, allowing you to easily incorporate Redtail into your existing tech stack.
  • Calendar System: This feature offers a bird’s eye view of schedules for the entire office. The Retriever Cloud tool takes it a step further by enabling sync with Office 365 and Google Calendar.
  • Seminar Management: The platform helps improve customer experience by going beyond simple event planning, doubling as a tracking tool for call and email campaigns.
  • Contact and Task Management: Redtail CRM excels in enabling teams to work together seamlessly. Users can easily collaborate on client-related tasks, ensuring that everyone stays on the same page and client needs are met.
  • Opportunity Tracker: This feature helps monitor and progress prospects or current clients through the sales process, keeping all open opportunities visible and manageable in one location.
  • Mobile Accessibility: Redtail’s free mobile app lets you access CRM data on the go. While it focuses only on core functions like managing contacts, calendars and opportunities, it provides the flexibility needed for professionals who are frequently away from their desks.
read more...
  • Dashboard: Get a visual overview of key metrics, activities and reports with a drag-and-drop customizable dashboard. Track metrics like average list price, average sales-to-close ratio, commission and upcoming appointments in real time. Collect useful insights for decision making at a glance. 
  • Calendar Management: Integrate with Google and iCalendar to get meetings, calls and appointment reminders in a timely manner. 
  • Campaign Management: Create and manage concurrent campaigns across multiple channels while tracking and optimizing them in real time to improve conversion rates. 
  • Contact Management: Store, organize, group and segment contacts centrally. Add tags and custom fields while using smart filters to search for contacts with similar attributes. Linear communication timelines make relevant information readily accessible. 
  • Email Marketing: Engage leads and build customer retention and loyalty through each stage of the buying journey with the email marketing module and customizable dynamic templates. 
  • Goal Tracking: Set up and track quantifiable time-based goals at the user, team, and organization levels to stay on the right track and maintain performance. 
  • Interaction Tracking: Track call and meeting details and attach notes for further information and follow-up activities. Track response rates for email interactions. 
  • Lead Management: Maintain a sales and marketing lead database while recording all marketing interactions between each prospect and the organization, including website visits, email clicks, scoring changes, and data updates and history. Also, track the sales activities for each prospect and their movement along the sales pipeline. 
  • Pop-By: Track clients in the vicinity and schedule visits through advanced mapping technology on the mobile version of the software. 
  • Priority Action Center: Get automatically populated to-do lists for the day with prompts for all activities such as calling prospects, writing notes and planning client meetings. 
  • Referral Tracking: Utilize an existing network of customers and users to send, receive, and track business referrals and sales leads. Keep networking activities up-to-date in one place. 
  • Reporting and Analytics: Access reports about data contained within the system, including sales, marketing and operational activities. Create ad hoc reports according to specific requirements. 
  • Task Management: Access an intuitive task management module that curates meetings and other important tasks and sets up automated reminders and notifications. 
  • Video Messages: Record and attach video messages to emails for increased engagement rates with an add-on feature. 
read more...

Product Ranking

#34

among all
CRM Software

#196

among all
CRM Software

Find out who the leaders are

User Sentiment Summary

Great User Sentiment 259 reviews
Great User Sentiment 42 reviews
86%
of users recommend this product

Redtail CRM has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 86% when considering 259 user reviews from 4 recognized software review sites.

86%
of users recommend this product

Referral Maker has a 'great' User Satisfaction Rating of 86% when considering 42 user reviews from 2 recognized software review sites.

4.4 (136)
n/a
n/a
4.31 (21)
4.1 (81)
4.3 (21)
5.0 (1)
n/a
4.5 (41)
n/a

Synopsis of User Ratings and Reviews

Competitive Pricing: Compared to other CRMs in the same price range, Redtail offers more advanced features while remaining affordable.
Transition Process: Migrating from another CRM to Redtail is well-supported and typically goes smoothly, minimizing disruption to your business operations during the transition.
User-Friendly Interface: Redtail CRM is easy to use and straightforward, even for users with varying levels of technical expertise.
Show more
Simple and Easy to Use: Referral Maker is praised for its user-friendly interface and intuitive design, making it easy for users of all technical levels to navigate and utilize its features effectively.
Effective Referral Tracking: The platform provides robust tools for tracking referrals, allowing users to monitor the progress of their referral campaigns and measure their success in real-time.
Customizable Referral Programs: Referral Maker offers a high degree of customization, enabling users to tailor their referral programs to their specific needs and goals, including setting custom rewards, designing unique referral links, and creating targeted campaigns.
Automated Referral Process: The platform automates key aspects of the referral process, such as sending referral invitations, tracking referrals, and distributing rewards, saving users time and effort.
Integrations with Popular Tools: Referral Maker integrates seamlessly with various popular CRM and marketing tools, allowing users to connect their referral program with their existing workflows and data.
Show more
Inconsistent Customer Support: Support agents sometimes struggle with simple requests, and the lack of direct phone numbers can make it difficult to get timely assistance. After the initial migration, users found ongoing support, training and assistance to be insufficient.
Technical Glitches: Users may encounter small bugs, such as incorrect information transfers or the creation of duplicate profiles when data doesn't match exactly.
Challenging Initial Setup: The initial configuration of Redtail, especially setting up workflows, can be difficult, making the implementation process time-consuming and complex.
Show more
Limited Integrations: Referral Maker's integrations with other business tools and platforms are limited, making it challenging to incorporate into existing workflows and hindering data synchronization with other essential systems.
Customization Constraints: The platform's customization options are somewhat restricted, potentially limiting the ability to tailor the referral program to specific branding and unique requirements.
Mobile App Deficiency: The absence of a dedicated mobile app can inconvenience users who prefer managing their referral programs on the go, potentially impacting engagement and responsiveness.
Show more

Testing Redtail CRM’s full Growth plan was a rollercoaster of impressions. I’d say it’s an adequate tool for finance professionals, but be prepared for a steep learning curve."One of Redtail's standout features is its workflow capabilities. I was impressed by how it helps build complex, detailed workflows to track each piece of business from start to finish. This undoubtedly prevents missed opportunities and service issues. That said, for smaller offices, this feature might be overkill, potentially creating more work than it saves.The customization options are extensive. You can tailor almost every field to fit specific business needs, which is great for those willing to invest the time to set it up properly. And therein lies the rub — it took a lot of trial and error to get the system working smoothly for our team.I appreciated the mobile syncing feature, which kept my contacts and calendar at my fingertips. The calendar view in Redtail is also quite good, and the ability to set different permissions for each staff member is a nice touch.The system can be frustratingly slow at times, and I experienced glitches, particularly when integrating with other software. So, expect some potential technical hiccups along the way.While Redtail is a good choice for managing workflows and generating professional-looking reports, I found it less suitable for complex marketing campaigns or deep customer data analysis. It's worth noting that it's designed specifically for the financial services industry, which limits its flexibility compared to more general CRM platforms.Redtail CRM is a potent tool that can be incredibly useful once you've climbed the steep learning curve. It's best suited for complicated teams in the financial services sector who are willing to invest time in learning its nuances and customizing it to their needs.

Show more

Is Referral Maker a cut above when it comes to making referrals? User reviews from the past year suggest that Referral Maker, while helpful for some, might not be the "referring" champion for everyone. Users appreciate its straightforward setup and ease of use, especially for those already familiar with Buffini & Company's systems. The program's task management and contact organization features are praised for keeping users on top of their client relationships, a crucial aspect of real estate. However, some users find the software's functionality somewhat limited compared to competitors like LionDesk or Top Producer CRM, particularly when it comes to advanced features and integrations. For instance, a lack of in-depth reporting tools and limited customization options are common complaints. Referral Maker seems best suited for real estate professionals already invested in the Buffini & Company ecosystem who prioritize simplicity and ease of use over a wider range of features. If you're looking for a basic CRM to manage contacts and stay organized, Referral Maker could be a good fit. However, if you require robust reporting, advanced automation, or integrations with other platforms, exploring alternatives might be worthwhile.

Show more

Screenshots

Top Alternatives in CRM Software


Copper CRM

Creatio

Dynamics 365 Sales

Freshsales

HubSpot Sales

Insightly

monday sales CRM

Nimble CRM

Oracle Sales Cloud

Pipedrive

Pipeliner CRM

Salesforce Sales Cloud

SAP Sales Cloud

Sugar Sell

Zendesk Sell

Zoho CRM

Related Categories

WE DISTILL IT INTO REAL REQUIREMENTS, COMPARISON REPORTS, PRICE GUIDES and more...

Compare products
Comparison Report
Just drag this link to the bookmark bar.
?
Table settings